Wrasse used as biological sea lice control in salmon farms raise serious welfare concerns; their complex social behavior and habitat needs are incompatible with salmon net-pen conditions.
Cleaner wrasse represent a welfare problem that exists entirely because they are instrumentally useful for another welfare problem (sea lice control in salmon). The conditions in which wrasse are expected to function - open net pens without shelter, territory, or social group structure appropriate to their needs - are fundamentally incompatible with their welfare. Wild capture adds additional welfare burden through capture stress and transport. The scale of use - 50+ million animals annually in Norway alone - makes this one of the largest individual welfare harms in aquaculture practice. Developing alternative lice control methods that do not require cleaner fish would resolve this welfare problem.