The welfare trade-offs between outdoor access and road traffic risk for cats require individual assessment rather than blanket indoor or outdoor policies.
Cat outdoor safety welfare requires contextual judgement: blanket indoor policies prevent enrichment-providing outdoor access; blanket outdoor policies in high-traffic areas accept preventable mortality. Location-specific risk assessment based on actual traffic density, cat temperament, and available alternatives allows welfare-positive decisions that balance safety against behavioural expression. Catio structures and garden enclosures provide a welfare-positive middle ground that protects cats from road risk while preserving outdoor enrichment.