The annual Canadian harp seal hunt is one of the most contested wildlife management programs globally, with welfare debates centering on the effectiveness of hakapik and rifle killing methods.
Independent welfare assessments of the seal hunt document significant rates of inadequate stunning, with animals wounded but not rendered insensible before skinning in some cases. The logistics of hunting on ice and with rifles at distance make consistent humane killing difficult. The hakapik, when used correctly, can kill instantly, but implementation is inconsistent.