Veal production has historically subjected male dairy calves to severe welfare deprivation; rose veal and reformed systems offer substantially better welfare outcomes for calves with commercial value.
Traditional white veal production subjected calves to extreme deprivation: individual crates preventing turning around, liquid-only diets causing iron deficiency and chronic hunger, and near-total social isolation. The reforms of the 1990s and 2007 were significant but incomplete — many countries still produce veal under poor conditions. Rose veal systems that allow movement, social contact, and solid food represent a meaningful welfare improvement while utilizing calves that would otherwise be killed without food use. The welfare hierarchy is clear: best for calves to nurse their mothers, then rose veal, then traditional white veal, then shot at birth.