Invasive rats have driven extinctions on islands globally; control programs cause significant welfare harm requiring ethical scrutiny.
Brodifacoum poisoning causes internal hemorrhaging over 5-7 days in rats, one of the most prolonged death methods used in conservation management. Rats are intelligent, social animals capable of suffering. The conservation case for island rat eradication is strong as extinctions are prevented. But the welfare cost is also significant. Research into more humane alternatives including fertility control deserves urgent investment.