Tail docking in pigs and sheep causes acute pain and may result in chronic neuropathic pain, while evidence for its effectiveness varies by species.
Tail docking in pigs addresses behavioral aggression caused by environmental deprivation rather than inherent vice. Docking does not eliminate tail biting — it reduces injury from biting that continues. In sheep, the welfare case is more complex with genuine flystrike prevention benefits in some breeds and conditions. Both species would benefit from reduced reliance on docking through system changes.