Wool is often presented as a natural, cruelty-free fiber. The welfare reality of commercial wool production is more complex and includes significant welfare concerns.
Wool production welfare issues are concentrated in two areas: mulesing and shearing practice. Mulesing — removing strips of skin around the breech of merino sheep — is performed without anesthesia on millions of lambs annually and causes significant acute pain. Its justification is prevention of flystrike, which is itself a serious welfare problem. The most welfare-compatible solution is breed selection for bare-breech genetics that eliminates both the mulesing and the flystrike risk simultaneously — a solution that New Zealand sheep farmers are increasingly adopting. Shearing practices vary enormously — professional shearers working quickly can be minimally stressful, but the PETA investigations document rough handling that causes bruising and injuries at scale.