Farm Animal Welfare
Tail biting in pigs is a serious welfare problem in intensive systems, caused by barren environments and redirected exploration behaviour, with tail docking used as a management response to a welfare problem created by the system itself.
Tail biting and tail docking represent a circular welfare failure: intensive systems create barren environments that cause biting, then respond with a painful mutilation rather than addressing the cause. Tail docking itself causes pain through nerve damage that can be permanent — docked pigs show pain behaviours and neuromas develop at the amputation site. The solution is well evidenced: providing adequate rooting material eliminates tail biting without the need for docking. The failure to implement this solution reflects the cost of providing straw in slatted floor systems and the path dependence of intensive production infrastructure. Regulatory enforcement of the enrichment requirement before docking is the most direct welfare intervention available through policy.