American bison were nearly driven to extinction; their restoration provides lessons about the welfare of conservation-managed megafauna and the challenges of ecological restoration.
Bison restoration is a welfare success story relative to near-extinction but a welfare work-in-progress relative to the pre-colonial abundance of free-ranging herds. Bison in conservation herds with adequate space and natural social structure experience genuinely good welfare compared to enclosed commercial animals. The welfare constraints of enclosed pasture keeping are significant — bison evolved to range across hundreds of miles seasonally — but the welfare improvement over commercial cattle production in equivalent land area is real. Expanding the land base for free-ranging bison is the most important welfare improvement available for this species.