Reindeer herding spans traditional Indigenous practices and intensive commercial farming. The welfare challenges differ across these contexts and require nuanced understanding.
Reindeer in traditional herding systems generally experience better welfare than those in intensive commercial operations, as herd sizes and movement patterns are more natural. However, the roundup and slaughter process, particularly in large commercial operations, involves significant stress. Antler velvet removal — cutting growing antlers from conscious animals — causes acute pain and is legal in many jurisdictions. Climate change impacts on reindeer welfare are emerging as a significant concern for both animal welfare and Indigenous livelihoods.