Tail docking of piglets is routinely performed without anesthesia to prevent tail-biting in intensive systems, but is a response to environmental deficiencies rather than an inherent pig behavior problem.
Tail docking is the agricultural equivalent of treating a symptom while ignoring the disease. Tail biting — the welfare problem docking is meant to address — is a behavioral indicator of environmental deficiency. Pigs in adequately enriched, appropriately stocked environments do not bite tails at rates requiring prevention through amputation. Docking without anesthesia causes acute pain in neonatal piglets and results in a sensitive nerve ending at the wound site that may cause chronic pain. The routine nature of the procedure normalizes what is, in effect, a painful surgery performed to compensate for inadequate housing conditions.