The vaquita is the world most critically endangered marine mammal, with fewer than 10 individuals remaining in the northern Gulf of California, and its survival depends on immediate and complete gillnet removal.
The vaquita situation represents conservation and welfare failure at its most acute. Each individual death — a drowning in a gillnet — is both a welfare tragedy and a significant population event. Drowning is a particularly distressing death for air-breathing mammals. The attempted captive rescue in 2017 demonstrated that vaquitas cannot survive capture and handling, collapsing the captive breeding option. The population is now so small that it may be past the point of demographic rescue — the remaining individuals may not have sufficient genetic diversity for long-term population viability. The welfare and conservation case for emergency complete gillnet removal in the vaquita refuge is overwhelming. The failure to implement it effectively reflects enforcement capacity limitations and the enormous economic incentives driving totoaba poaching.