Tail docking of piglets is widely practiced to prevent tail biting in intensive systems, but is itself a painful procedure that treats a symptom rather than the underlying welfare problem.
Tail docking presents a welfare paradox: it is a painful procedure performed to prevent a painful outcome. Piglets docked without anesthesia show clear pain responses including vocalizations, struggling, and elevated stress hormones. However, the tail biting it is meant to prevent causes even more severe welfare harm, including infection, blood loss, and death. The real solution is to address the root causes of tail biting — overcrowding, boredom, and lack of enrichment — rather than performing a painful procedure on every piglet to protect against a problem that better management could prevent. Countries with successful intact-tail production demonstrate that docking is not inevitable in pig farming.