Polar bears are among the most controversial animals to keep in captivity. Their wide-ranging Arctic lifestyle, complex behavior, and sensitivity to heat make standard zoo environments profoundly challenging for their welfare.
Polar bear welfare in captivity is one of the most difficult to achieve. Their extraordinary ranging behavior, specialized diet, and thermal physiology are all fundamentally incompatible with standard zoo enclosures. The prevalence of stereotypic pacing in captive polar bears — a strong indicator of chronic stress and welfare failure — is among the highest of any captive species. Even the best zoo programs with large, cold, enriched pools provide a tiny fraction of what polar bears experience in the wild. Some accredited zoos have honestly concluded that they cannot provide adequate polar bear welfare and have ended their programs. The welfare case for keeping polar bears in captivity deserves rigorous scrutiny.