Tail biting is a severe welfare problem in intensive pig production, caused by barren environments and overcrowding, yet the industry response is typically to dock tails rather than address the root causes.
Tail biting represents a welfare failure at two levels: the environmental conditions that trigger the behaviour, and the industry response of routinely docking tails to prevent injury rather than addressing the cause. A pig living in a barren, overcrowded environment with a docked tail is not in adequate welfare — the docking has merely prevented one form of injury while the underlying deprivation continues. The EU regulatory framework recognises this but fails in practice because enforcement of enrichment requirements is inadequate.