Routine tail docking of piglets without anaesthesia is widely practiced in intensive pig farming to prevent tail biting. This painful procedure is a symptom of welfare deficits rather than a solution to them.
Tail docking treats the symptom — tail biting — while leaving the cause — barren, overcrowded, frustrating environments — intact. It is a painful intervention performed on a non-consenting animal to enable a production system that falls below welfare standards. Countries like Sweden and Norway have achieved low tail biting incidence without routine docking through mandatory enrichment and better housing. The persistence of tail docking in intensive systems reflects a regulatory and enforcement failure, not a technical impossibility of improvement.