Tail docking of piglets is routine in industrial pig farming, intended to prevent tail biting. But it is both painful and unnecessary when root causes are addressed. Reform means improving conditions, not just the procedure.
Tail docking addresses a symptom — tail biting — while leaving its cause intact. When pigs bite each other's tails, it signals an environment that fails to meet their behavioural needs: overcrowded, understimulating, nutritionally inadequate, or painful from other sources. Docking creates its own welfare problem through acute procedural pain and chronic neuroma pain at the stump. The welfare-optimal solution is root cause reduction: lower stocking density, enrichment provision, adequate nutrition, and early intervention when biting begins. Achieving this at industrial scale requires both regulatory enforcement and farmer support. The Danish intact tail trial shows it is achievable, but requires systemic change rather than individual farm effort alone.