Early socialisation during the critical window of 3-12 weeks is the strongest determinant of adult dog welfare, temperament, and risk of fear and anxiety disorders.
Socialisation quality in the critical window is the single most influential factor in adult dog welfare, outweighing genetics and adult training in determining fear and anxiety risk. Puppies that miss this window due to inadequate breeder socialisation, early separation, or illness often develop chronic fear that cannot be fully remediated in adulthood. Breeders bear primary responsibility for the socialisation window given that most puppies leave for their new homes after it has already substantially closed. Puppy class attendance during the window is recommended by all major veterinary behaviour organisations.