Tail docking of piglets is a routine preventive procedure in intensive pig farming. The welfare evidence strongly supports addressing root causes rather than continuing routine docking.
Tail docking welfare illustrates a common pattern in intensive farming: mutilating animals to prevent injuries caused by the farming system rather than addressing the system conditions that cause the injuries. Tail biting is a welfare problem driven by overcrowding, barren environments, and frustrated rooting behavior. Tail docking reduces the injury from biting but does not address the underlying welfare failure that drives biting behavior. The acute pain of docking and the potential for chronic tail stump sensitivity add welfare costs to an animal that is already in a welfare-compromised system. The evidence from enrichment-focused systems demonstrates that adequate rooting material provision makes routine docking unnecessary — addressing the root cause rather than treating the symptom.