Tail biting in pigs is a serious welfare problem in intensive systems, and routine tail docking — performed without analgesia to reduce biting risk — creates an ethical dilemma about preventive surgery.
Tail biting and its preventive response, tail docking, represent interconnected welfare failures. Tail biting is fundamentally a behavioral disorder driven by environments that fail to meet pigs' behavioral needs. The industry response — removing the tail rather than addressing root causes — imposes acute surgical pain to prevent a welfare problem caused by the system. Docking without analgesia causes significant pain. Addressing tail biting at its source through enrichment and improved stocking density is both more ethical and increasingly required by welfare certifications.