Wool production involves annual shearing that is necessary for sheep welfare in some breeds but performed under conditions that vary enormously in their welfare quality.
Wool production from breeds that require shearing is not inherently exploitative — the sheep genuinely need shearing for welfare reasons. The ethical question concerns the conditions under which shearing occurs. Investigations have documented rough handling and poor shearing practice in various supply chains. Welfare-positive shearing uses trained shearers working at appropriate speed, with sheep held gently in shearer-specific positions rather than thrown or restrained forcefully. Certification schemes like the RWS provide the most accessible route for consumers to support better shearing welfare, though independent verification of compliance is essential.