Pre-slaughter stunning of farmed fish is an ethical imperative supported by science but inconsistently implemented across the aquaculture industry.
Pre-slaughter suffering in fish is one of the largest-scale welfare problems in animal agriculture, affecting billions of individuals annually. Asphyxiation in ice slurry can take several minutes of conscious distress. Carbon dioxide causes aversive chemical burn of gill membranes before unconsciousness. Electrical and percussive stunning, when properly applied, eliminate or minimize pre-slaughter suffering. The welfare case for mandatory stunning is strong and the technology exists.