Tail biting causes severe welfare harm to pigs and requires proactive, multi-factorial prevention programs rather than reactive tail docking.
Tail biting is a catastrophic welfare failure - the victim experiences acute pain and trauma while the behavior spreads as other pigs investigate blood. Corrective measures including tail docking address symptoms not causes. The real welfare solution is eliminating the risk factors that drive tail biting: insufficient space, inadequate enrichment, disease, resource competition, and poor air quality. Farms that successfully maintain intact-tailed pigs demonstrate that these problems are solvable with sufficient management commitment.