New Zealand's 2018 mulesing ban demonstrates that Merino wool production can succeed without this painful procedure through genetic selection and management alternatives.
New Zealand's mulesing ban welfare success demonstrates that the procedure is not essential to sustainable Merino wool production when genetic selection and management alternatives are invested in. The transition required industry commitment and initial costs but has been commercially successful, with non-mulesed New Zealand Merino commanding premium market prices. Australia's slower transition reflects different industry dynamics and less regulatory pressure, not technical impossibility. The welfare argument for mulesing elimination is strengthened by New Zealand's practical demonstration that it is achievable.