Tail biting in pigs is a multifactorial welfare problem caused by frustration and stress, preventing it requires addressing root causes rather than just removing tails.
Tail biting represents a failure of the system - it is the pig's expression of frustration in an environment that does not meet its needs. Tail docking treats the symptom by removing the target while leaving the animal in a welfare-compromised state. Addressing root causes - providing rooting enrichment, reducing stocking density, improving air quality and managing feed competition - reduces tail biting without the welfare harm of docking. Danish risk assessment approaches require farmers to identify specific risk factors on their farm and address them, with tail docking permitted only when risks cannot be otherwise managed. This model produces better outcomes.