Pig tail docking is a painful mutilation used to prevent tail biting, but addressing root causes of biting is the preferred welfare solution.
Tail docking causes acute pain at the time of procedure and may cause chronic pain at the amputation site. It treats the symptom rather than the cause of tail biting - which itself is a serious welfare problem. The welfare-positive approach is to improve housing conditions and provide enrichment so tail biting is prevented at source, eliminating the need for mutilation.