Silk production involves the killing of billions of silkworm pupae annually, and the welfare status of insects like silkworms is an increasingly active scientific question.
Silk welfare represents one of the more uncertain animal welfare questions: silkworms are insects whose sentience is debated, domesticated to the point where wild survival is impossible, and killed in enormous quantities. If insects can experience pain — evidence for which is growing but not conclusive — silk production causes significant suffering. Ahimsa silk avoids killing pupae at the cost of fiber quality. Plant-based silk alternatives including spider-silk proteins produced by fermentation are in commercial development.